Democrats Heading to Failure

The Off-Topic forum for anything non-LDS related, such as sports or politics. Rated PG through PG-13.
Chap
God
Posts: 3324
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 8:42 am
Location: On the imaginary axis

Re: Democrats Heading to Failure

Post by Chap »

huckelberry wrote: ↑
Sat Nov 21, 2026 6:26 pm
Gad referenced long waits for non critical dental care in England inferring that showed the general condition of health care under their system. Chap replied their is a longstanding hole in coverage for non emergency dental cleaning. It sounds like Chap does not accept that as accurate portrait of their system as a whole. It appears Chap holds a generally positive view of the system there.
Thanks huckleberry! NHS service where I spend my time in the UK can be characterised as follows:
  1. In an emergency I dial 999 and ask for an ambulance with paramedics - that is normally a very quick service if you don't live out in the wilds. If I am not that urgent, but I can make a case that my need for medical advice/treatment is fairly pressing (I can speak on the phone or fill in an online form to make my case) I can get to see someone from my habitual generalist team for no fee on the same day. The decision about my request is made by the 'duty doctor' from the team whose turn it is that day. If I want to see one particular member of the team and things are not urgent, it may take a few days, sometimes longer. For things like routine blood tests, there are nurses on the team that I can see.
  2. I can also just go straight to the Accident and Emergency department of my local hospital, but although my local hospital is a nice enough place, there can be very long waits if you go when it is crowded. To be avoided if possible.
  3. Treatment of life-threatening disease is available pretty rapidly. Some things such as (e.g.) a painful knee joint that needs replacing with an artificial joint may however involve long waits.
It's all free at point of use, apart from a standard charge for prescribed medicines with exemptions for certain age-groups and for those with chronic diseases.

Biggest problem faced by the system: reluctance of successive governments to take enough tax revenue to pay what the system needs to keep running well. But if you explained to British people what they would have to pay a US private insurance company to provide the same service level I don't think they would choose to switch systems.

Also - the quality of the service can vary depending on where you live. Oddly enough, the best experience is delivered in the areas where people are not badly off ... in part because that is where doctors prefer to live and work, which is no surprise.

As I have said. other systems of universal health-care are available and I have experience of them. But the above is today's dose of in real life from me.

(What an unpleasant know-all foreigner I am! And, as has been pointed out, a rabid socialist with communist leanings. Discovered, curses!!!)
Maksutov:
That's the problem with this supernatural stuff, it doesn't really solve anything. It's a placeholder for ignorance.
Mayan Elephant:
Not only have I denounced the Big Lie, I have denounced the Big lie big lie.
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6935
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Democrats Heading to Failure

Post by Gadianton »

Doc Cam wrote:but when the left talks about universal healthcare (UC), we’re not talking about the government taking over hospitals, drug companies, or medical research. We’re talking about making sure people can get healthcare without going into debt or risking financial ruin. Which is happening far too often.
Generally, sure -- I'm completely onboard. Who wouldn't want that as a goal? Well, I mean, what good and rational person wouldn't want that as a goal? I suppose my point is, if that's the goal, let's review all possible ways to achieve that. El-Sayed wrote a book about healthcare reform with the goal of getting rid of part C in the long term, and in the short term, expanding medicare to everyone with billionares paying for it, or something, in theory I'm for it but far fetched; and this is part of the blue-maga narrative, I think.
Also, I don’t mean to be a dick, but pharmaceutical innovation isn’t funded solely by private capital. I believe the HHS has plowed billions upon billions into R&D.
I'm also open to reviewing funding options for research, I don't have any hard opinions here as my knowledge is pretty superficial, my only point was that as it is today, there are a lot of so-called good-hearted socialist societies benefitting from the so-called hardships of Americans due to patent monopolies both here and abroad.
The Left is just asking better stewardship of our resources
Totally on board, hence my suggestion to close down all the fake ERrs, for starters. I suggest that both roads be examined, the MRI thing isn't isolated, I bring it up because of my own experience with it, but there is a fledgling industry of cash-only medical services including doctors where you can pay 100$ a month and that's your doctor. I don't know a whole lot about it, but should be part of what's reviewed.

In general, I'd expect routine medicine to work better with some kind of market incentive and extreme medicine and trauma, where risk-pooling (with adverse selection, externalities etc.) is better socialized, but recognizing that designing cutting-edge capabilities for such a system without market incentive is dicey.
Last edited by Gadianton on Sun Nov 22, 2026 2:23 am, edited 1 time in total.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6935
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Democrats Heading to Failure

Post by Gadianton »

Chap wrote:I don't recognise the entity called "Chap" who is frequently cited in Gadianton's recent posts. "Raping America"? Wow!
Just giving you a hard time, that's all. I believe the word I used was Chap "freeloading". The word you quote I used to refer to the combined American/Euro for-profit pharma. Obviously, that was hyperbole, given that in the same sentence I exaggerated the small size of European countries as adding to 750 people. And in fact, choosing that term was meant to portray how enlightened socialists view the American elite treating the American people, yet it's also the European elite treating the American people in the same way. And so European socialists should be careful about how smugly they speak of American capitalists, when European capitalists are doing the same thing for the ultimate benefit of their own dear socialized programs.
What an unpleasant know-all foreigner I am!
Actually, I think you have it backwards. I enjoyed your fact-based anectode immensely. These are the kinds of discussions that people in America need to get used to having if they are serious about reforming their system.

The vague dismissals of "free market" and insurance companies are the problem, and oh, Gad is going to weep for insurance executives, and I can get health care for free and no risks anytime I want. And then, even though I wrote a moderate-length post complaining about various aspects of the current system, you're like, "haha Gad if you're happy with it as it is, enjoy!"

That's the unpleasent know-all foreigner. Though, this is a free speech forum so feel free, but I'd vote for the fact-based posts.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6935
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Democrats Heading to Failure

Post by Gadianton »

huckelberry wrote: ↑
Sat Nov 21, 2026 6:26 pm
Gad referenced long waits for non critical dental care in England inferring that showed the general condition of health care under their system. Chap replied their is a longstanding hole in coverage for non emergency dental cleaning. It sounds like Chap does not accept that as accurate portrait of their system as a whole. It appears Chap holds a generally positive view of the system there.

Gad refers to part c Medicare to point out that Medicare coverage is limited enough people must buy some sort of further privately offered insurance. I must pay a monthly chunk to supplement wife and my Medicare.

Medicare for all is a slogan not a plan or solution.
My point wasn't to generalize their system by pointing out the long-wait times for dental care at all. That would be a huge mistake. My point was that markets seem to cover certain aspects of medical care better than socialized programs. Emergency care and expensive treatments are covered better by Chap's program, I'm pretty sure, though, as I pointed out, the picture is far more complicated and doesn't make that a clean victory over American greed.

You make a further point than I was making about Medicare C. I mean, that's actually a good point. I skipped my point about Medicare C. My point about C is that 55% of people on Medicare get their coverage through private providers because it's (often) cheaper, and that utilization is predicted to go up from here. The most basic part of this point, is that there is no reason to believe, without further information, that going to a "universal system" would get rid of insurance companies when insurance companies are everyday more entrenched in the part of American medicine that is already socialized.

Eh hum, in California, nearly 60% use Medicare Advantage, the nation leader. In Kentucky, it's the low 40s. So it's not a red state thing.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
User avatar
Doctor CamNC4Me
God
Posts: 11209
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 2:04 am

Re: Democrats Heading to Failure

Post by Doctor CamNC4Me »

What about the markets that fail? The for-profit hospital that closes in rural Louisiana shows that capitalism doesn’t always work out.

Okay, but what a hub-n-spoke approach to regional healthcare? We’ll have a regional hospital filled with all the people and things with smaller clinics dotting the landscape that offers practical care.

Sounds great until Todd strokes out, he has to wait 35 minutes for an amberlamps and then it’s a 50 minute ride to Baton Rouge. He’s probably dead and capitalism failed him.

Worse, take a big city hospital that closes. Streamlined hospital beds are great for the bottom line, but capitalism lacks if there’s bad mgmt, controlling interests conflict, aging hospitals cost more to update than they make, etc. Capitalism fails patients when it can’t overcome its own directive: be profitable.

Maybe some day hustle culture will catch up to the medical profession and we’ll have MRI trucks next to the food trucks at events. I dunno. Ask nurses working at a hospital if capitalism is working for them. Yes they have a job, but are they being compensated fairly? I doubt they’ll be cheerleading the conglomerate that owns and runs their hospitals.
Hiring a part-time news entertainment anchor as SecDef, what could go wrong?
User avatar
Some Schmo
God
Posts: 4078
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 3:21 am

Re: Democrats Heading to Failure

Post by Some Schmo »

Doctor CamNC4Me wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 22, 2026 10:35 am
Maybe some day hustle culture will catch up to the medical profession and we’ll have MRI trucks next to the food trucks at events. I dunno. Ask nurses working at a hospital if capitalism is working for them. Yes they have a job, but are they being compensated fairly? I doubt they’ll be cheerleading the conglomerate that owns and runs their hospitals.
I was listening to a guy talking about how the medical profession is losing a lot of professionals due to being asked to worry more about whether someone can pay for care or not over concentrating on giving care.

Not surprising at all.

Gad, it's just as easy to throw up your hands and say it won't work without insurance companies as it is for me to say the US system sucks and needs reform. Of course, I've been saying what I said in the post that seemed to set you off for literally years now, since before the ACA. I won't pretend to be an expert on healthcare systems (a damned red herring if I've ever read one). I understand that my view is unrealistic for the US, because the US electorate has been brainwashed into thinking the market is the solution to everything.

You can't convince Americans their view on guns is screwed up either, because Americans are very attached to their brainwashing, which includes how damned awesome America is (if you un-focus your eyes and ignore the massive warts), and if you don't like it, just leave.

Here's to never accepting slight adjustment or correction.*

*Elbow lyric from Things I've Been Telling Myself for Years
Religion is for people whose existential fear is greater than their common sense. It's also the favored cover for hypocrites.

The god idea is popular with desperate people.
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6935
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Democrats Heading to Failure

Post by Gadianton »

Doctor Cam wrote:What about the markets that fail? The for-profit hospital that closes in rural Louisiana shows that capitalism doesn’t always work out.
Let's go back to what I said in my last post, "In general, I'd expect routine medicine to work better with some kind of market incentive and extreme medicine and trauma, where risk-pooling (with adverse selection, externalities etc.) is better socialized"

If you take that as my basic framework, then it's not surprising at all that for-profit hospitals don't work. In fact, one of my first points was that for-profit ERs should be shut down immediately.
Sounds great until Todd strokes out, he has to wait 35 minutes for an amberlamps and then it’s a 50 minute ride to Baton Rouge. He’s probably dead and capitalism failed him.
A further issue due to American geography that England doesn't have. But people die in English ambulances all the time due to NHS unable to get them a bed at a hospital. This, interestingly, is due to the fact that emergency care is free, but nursing home care isn't, it's subsidized, but not guaranteed. That means that once the emergency is over, the patient may have nowhere to get discharged to and so takes up the bed.
Capitalism fails patients when it can’t overcome its own directive: be profitable.
I don't disagree, in fact, my view is even more extreme that yours, that if policy isn't well thought out, capitalism first chews on the fat policy opens up for it rather than actually providing something that benefits anyone. It's not just a matter of helping somebody only if they can make a buck, but first try to make the buck without helping anyone.
Ask nurses working at a hospital if capitalism is working for them
Well, it may be true that low-ranking nurses get treated badly in capitalism just like non-skilled labor generally does in capitalism. But, ranking nurses are among the highest paid in the world.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6935
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Democrats Heading to Failure

Post by Gadianton »

Schmo wrote:Gad, it's just as easy to throw up your hands and say it won't work without insurance companies as it is for me to say the US system sucks and needs reform.
I think you misunderstand my point, Schmo. I'm saying the opposite of what you think I'm saying. I'm saying it (probably) won't work with insurance companies! If there's nothing else you get from my posts, try to remember that much.
Of course, I've been saying what I said in the post that seemed to set you off for literally years now, since before the ACA.
Years ago I probably wasn't paying attention. I was a late bloomer when it comes to politics. I didn't even vote until 2020. The reason you may have set me off now rather than a couple years ago is now that there's a blue wave, there's power to make changes, and it's time to transition from "Republicans and billionaires all suck", which is true, to considering what that change should be. You specifically cited insurance companies as bad. I don't disagree. However, the shortest policy path between here and more health coverage for people involves expanding Medicare coverage, and Medicare coverage is increasingly administered by insurance companies who are raking in profits from it (to the detriment of the system, most likely), and since you may not have known what Medicare Advantage is, you may not know that when that "slight adjustment" comes, you're most likely going to unwittingly expand the footprint of private insurance companies.
I won't pretend to be an expert on healthcare systems (a damned red herring if I've ever read one).
Well, somebody is eventually going to need to be an expert on it, doesn't need to be you, but I'll bet Chap and Physics Guy know a whole lot more about how their own respective systems work than you know about how yours works. Might want to change that if you want to vote for a solution that reduces the footprint of insurance companies.
I understand that my view is unrealistic for the US, because the US electorate has been brainwashed into thinking the market is the solution to everything.
What is your viewpoint aside from partisan outrage? It's not true that the US electorate has been brainwashed to think the market is the solution. Most liberals, who there are more of, think the market is evil. It seems like the US electorate, right now, is open to government fixing their problems. In my view, the semi-but-not-totally good intentions of blue politicians is going to end up throwing more fat to the wolves for minor improvements to the underinsured
Here's to never accepting slight adjustment or correction.*
Interesting you say that because so far, in this thread, I've suggested a few adjustments and I have one or two others that are implied. Nobody else has made any suggestions at all.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
Post Reply