What's Your Take on Near Death Experiences?

The upper-crust forum for scholarly, polite, and respectful discussions only. Heavily moderated. Rated G.
Post Reply
_Ray A

Post by _Ray A »

ajax18 wrote:Ray have you gotten any information on the idea of a universal resurrection? I know people don't want to go back to their bodies, but what conclusion have you come to?


I don't know of any NDE experincers who have spoken of resurrection. Maybe Quantumwave does, as he's quite knowledgeable in this field as well. Here is a excerpt from Kevin Williams' site which may help (My emphases):

Faulty religious doctrines: Within some religions are various sects or denominations that are often based upon the magnification of some particular religious doctrine. Below are some insights about this:

(1)


Some Christians expect heaven to be a place where people stand in front of the throne, worshipping forever. Such a view of heaven is boring and childlike. There are so many heavenly realms and in each of them there is a fractal that is your particular interpretation, unless you are part of the group soul that believes in only the God of a particular religion. (Mellen-Thomas Benedict)



(2)


Insincere prayers of repetition have little, if any, light. These, having no power, are not heard. But there is no prayer greater than that of a mother for her children. (Betty Eadie)



(3)


The belief that we are separate from God is the only real sin. (Dr. PMH Atwater)



(4)


When we die, there is no so-called Judgment Day involving the hellfire and brimstone that is described in the Bible. God judges no one. The only judgment is self-judgment. (Sherry Gideon)



(5)


We do not sit at the feet of a man with a long white beard called God.�God is within, whether you are in or out of the body. (Betty Bethards)



(6)


There is no doctrine and no belief to pursue other than knowing that the Being of Light is God. (Norman Paulsen)



(7)


When we enter the spirit realm, we are given glimpses of things we expected to see in order to bring us comfort.�We may briefly see a teacher we worshipped in our lifetime: Jesus, Buddha, or another guru, according to your expectations. But gently we are brought out of many of our illusions and are shown that we have not landed in an ultimate paradise with gold paved streets. (Betty Bethards)



(8)


It is not true, as some people think, that if we only give verbal assent to belief in God, that is our passport to heaven and everything will be all right. Not so. God helps those who help themselves. (Margaret Tweddell)



(9)


We do not go to heaven by worshipping Jesus, or by believing in his name, or by believing in his work on the cross, or by accepting him as our Savior. The way to heaven is through love. God is love. We grow to heaven by allowing love to grow in our hearts and create heaven within us by practicing unconditional love. (Kevin Williams)



(10)


Being a Christian is not enough to attain heaven. We grow to heaven by emulating the love of Jesus rather than by worshipping Jesus. (Kevin Williams)



(11)


If you insist upon searching for God, you will do this for a while until you get the idea that you are following an illusion. God is love in all religions, so the more we live love the closer we are to God. (Betty Bethards)



(12)


Religious beliefs can limit an open mind. Any belief such as soul sleep, God on a throne, angels with wings, the trinity, etc. etc., is initially carried over at the time of death, but very soon, all beliefs that don't correlate with afterlife reality will just simply not be believed anymore. This is all a process of instruction. (Kevin Williams)


The resurrection is religious mythology, that's my opinion. We are part of a universal consciousness, and though we presently perceive ourselves as individuals in, well basically, animal bodies (we share 99% of our bological makeup with chimps, and chimpanzees are closer biologically to humans than they are to gorillas), everything in the universe is really ONE. Once again I think Buddhism is the religion that comes closest to this idea, and Buddhism has no concept of resurrection. If you'd like to read a good book covering this topic I recommend Darryl Reanney's The Death of Forever: A New Future for Human Consciousness. He has written a couple of books on speculative metaphysics, which you can find Here

Reanney started out as a skeptic, wanting to critique "fluffy" ideas about an afterlife and the possible survival of death, and some ten years later had a complete change of heart. He was an internationally recognised authority on the origin of life, and a microbiologist who taught biochemistry at the University of Canterbury in New Zealand, and at LaTrobe University in Australia, and hosted the ABC program "Genesis", a seven part series about genes and evolution. He admitted that he may have gone too far with speculation for the tastes of "empirical science", but his change of ideas, I think, was significant. Here is what one commentator said:

After Death, A New Future for Human Consciousness by Darryl Reanney

I saved this book for last because it is my all time favorite text on the subject of death. Unfortunately for the planet Darryl Reanney died of leukemia while working on his second book so we will not have the benefit of his thoughtful and painstakingly exact logic on this subject again. However, as a molecular biologist his study of death covers physiological, psychological, historical, philosophical and cosmological aspects. It is one of the most beautiful and elegant presentations of man's thinking on the subject and his analytical structure and conscientious word style allows any novice thinker to follow his train of thought and ponder along the way. I have read this book many times and intend to continue to do so. My hope is that anyone with an interest or a fear in the business of life will take time to read this book about death.


I too recommend The Death of Forever, but I have not read Music of the Mind. This link may help you to understand more about Reanney: http://www.actualfreedom.com.au/actuali ... eanney.htm

And a quote from the book:

Now, however, we reach the threshold of the truly mysterious, for we must look to the far reaches of physics, to the paradox-ridden realms of the very small and the very large. There await us bejewelled creatures, strange beyond dreaming, that are born of the highest faculties of the human mind. In this mirror, we will see almost nothing we recognize. Does this mean that we are abandoning reality for illusion? Not at all: we are doing just the reverse. In reaching this far into the realm of the invisible, away from the homely metaphors of everyday life, we are approaching reality. We must not complain if we find it strange. Indeed, it is this very strangeness that tells us that we are ‘on the right track’. When science was young common sense was our guide. The model of the world we built up from new discoveries was based on familiar objects – clocks, pistons, billiard balls. As science has progressed through its great conceptual revolutions – relativity, quantum mechanics, super symmetry – its discoveries have become more exotic, more remote from everyday experience. Easily recognizable images based on familiar things have given way to abstract theorems which tell of particles moving backwards in time, of a universe structured in eleven dimensions and so on. During this process, the status of common sense has been inverted: no longer our guide in the search for truth, it has become our adversary. D. Reanney, The Death of Forever – A New Future for Human Consciousness. Longman 1991, p. 138


This is the problem I see: Religions teach totally fanciful mythologies, and science is often too blind to new discoveries which could completely overturn our understanding of the universe. It seems at the moment to be an unhealthy choice, religious mythology, or "nihilistic science", when you are dead, that is the total end of you. I find both extremes lacking, and depressing to some extent, and not open to new ideas as Reanney was.

From my studies, I don't believe in a resurrection, but I DO believe that human consciousness survives death. Who we are is not just a body of flesh. We are mind, spirit, and intelligence. Our bodies are "vechicles of expression" on many, many different levels, from animals to humans. The problem with religion is that it basically feeds the ego, not the healthy ego, but the self-seeking ego hooked on what is called "maya", or "the illusion", because in the end material possessions, fame, wealth or status, will mean absolutely nothing, including tryng to prove one's religion "right". This is just more status seeking. The only thing that will matter is how we connect to the universe and improve through learning and loving. I believe that religions, and many "sacred" writings, are just there as primers, and some reflect the darker side of human nature. "Chosen people", "only true churches", "only truths", are just a manifestation of EGO, and these lead to contentions and hypocrisy. This is where I do believe that religion can actually make good people BAD. Their ego feeds on being "right", and seeing their fellow human beings suffer for not making "the right choice". I find this type of thinking to be abject stupidity, and conducive to human devolution, not evolution. We must rise above our narrow sectarian agendas, and even our narrow "empirical science" ideas, and start to think like Darryl Reanney, open to a future we can scarcely even now imagine. As Paul Davies said, we are not here by mistake, we are here for a purpose. The universe has meaning and direction, and we are like children trying to discover it. Everything in life has meaning, even all that we suffer. But I guess I'm getting too much like Reanney now, thinking that we can go beyond narrow paradigms.

I am, in the end, an optimist, and I believe that our lives have purpose, and we are not here by accident, and each of us is part of a growing and evolving universe, even if we have not yet "got the picture". We will never "get it" through silly religious fundamentalism, or dead end "empirical" dogmas.
_Quantumwave
_Emeritus
Posts: 79
Joined: Mon Nov 06, 2006 6:35 pm

Post by _Quantumwave »

Ray A wrote:
ajax18 wrote:Ray have you gotten any information on the idea of a universal resurrection? I know people don't want to go back to their bodies, but what conclusion have you come to?


I don't know of any NDE experincers who have spoken of resurrection. Maybe Quantumwave does, as he's quite knowledgeable in this field as well.




Hi Ray,

I don’t recall seeing the subject of resurrection in relation to NDE information. As you know, it is a generally accepted precept by spiritualists that we take our present knowledge and beliefs with us when we pass over, and I read somewhere that those who believe they must wait to be resurrected will wait for a time proportional to the strength of their belief, until they can be revived from this state of suspended animation. I looked for the reference in my files without success, so for what it's worth.
Men never do evil so completely and cheerfully as when they do it from religious conviction. –Blaise Pascal
Without it, you'd have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, it takes religion. -Stephen Weinberg
_ajax18
_Emeritus
Posts: 6914
Joined: Wed Oct 25, 2006 2:56 am

Post by _ajax18 »

Thanks for the replies guys. Do you have any good opinion/information on ghost stories. I know some people think it's all bogus, while others sware it happened.
And when the confederates saw Jackson standing fearless as a stone wall the army of Northern Virginia took courage and drove the federal army off their land.
_Ray A

Post by _Ray A »

ajax18 wrote:Thanks for the replies guys. Do you have any good opinion/information on ghost stories. I know some people think it's all bogus, while others sware it happened.


There are many, but this one is worth looking at: http://theshadowlands.net/ghost/
_Dr. Shades
_Emeritus
Posts: 14117
Joined: Mon Oct 23, 2006 9:07 pm

Post by _Dr. Shades »

Hi Ray:

Thanks very much for posting that. I have some questions for you:

Assuming for the sake of the argument that life-after-death is real, sometimes returnees report going to Hell. What's your opinion as to the veracity of that? If they're not lying, what percentage of departed souls go there, and what qualifies someone to go there?
"Finally, for your rather strange idea that miracles are somehow linked to the amount of gay sexual gratification that is taking place would require that primitive Christianity was launched by gay sex, would it not?"

--Louis Midgley
_Ray A

Post by _Ray A »

Dr. Shades wrote:Hi Ray:

Thanks very much for posting that. I have some questions for you:

Assuming for the sake of the argument that life-after-death is real, sometimes returnees report going to Hell. What's your opinion as to the veracity of that? If they're not lying, what percentage of departed souls go there, and what qualifies someone to go there?


Shades, yes there are reports of hellish NDEs, but they are only a very small minority. I've posted Howard Storm's many times on boards, but in case you missed it: http://www.near-death.com/storm.html

Hell is not a permanent state and as you saw from the link, Storm was immediately delivered upon asking (and turned from an atheist to a minister of religion, but I should qualify that Storm does have very liberal religious beliefs now, he is no fundamentalist and is also open to various interpretations of his NDE). No one knows what causes hellish NDEs, and it's not consistent. You may have a criminal, wicked person, having a "glorious" NDE (always followed by radical behavioural change for the better), and you may have a moral person having a hellish NDE, even devout Christians have had hellish NDEs. However, an NDE, good or bad, is not an indication of what the person's "final state" may be, and I don't believe there are "final states", as everyone is allowed to progress according to their ability and choice. This link from Kevin's site may help:
http://www.near-death.com/experiences/research14.html

As with heaven, there are various hell realms witnessed by near-death experiencers. We can even see many manifestations of hell right here in the physical realm. There are people in prison, in the Bahamas, in mental institutions, universities, skid row, palaces, crack houses, all kinds of life situations. While hell realms can be seen outside all around the world as a manifestation of an inner hell within humans, hell realms in the spirit world are an even greater manifestation of inner hell within humans. Near-death accounts show that the hell realms in the spirit world are actually the spiritual/mental manifestations of spiritual conditions that humans create within themselves while on earth. Between the earth realm and the heavenly realms, there exists two hellish realms known as (1) the earthbound realm and (2) the void. Both of these realms can be considered hell because they are the two darker levels. This web page will focus only on the earthbound realm. The earthbound realm is a hellish dimension that overlaps the physical realm. It is a dimension where souls who are bound by some strong earthly fixation, may remain indefinitely until they are able to extract themselves from this fixation. After death, most souls expand very quickly through the dark hellish realms of the earthbound realm and the void, by means of the tunnel and on to higher realms.


We've all heard the expression "I'm in hell", or "my life is hell". It's really a "learning curve", so to speak. We can experience hell right here on earth. Don't need an NDE for that.

Physical desires can be carried over into the afterlife but physical desires cannot be satisfied there. This can create a hellish condition for those who have them. (Nora Spurgin)


Again I refer to the Eightfold Path of Buddhism:
http://www.thebigview.com/buddhism/eightfoldpath.html

Right view, right intention, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right mindfulness, right effort, right concentration. Buddhist do believe in hell, by the way, but not as a permanent state. It comes from incorrect thinking and behaviour. The moral teachings of most religions tie in with what we know of NDEs, yes, including Mormonism. Think of Alma's experience, though I firmly believe this is a fictional account, it ties in very well with hellish NDEs, and with Howard Storm's experience.

More from Kevin's site:

Hell is Neither Condemnation Nor Judgment

There is no condemnation in hell, only the outworking of our own misjudgments, mistakes, misalignments, or misappropriations. (Dr. PMH Atwater)

Those with too many negative thought patterns might flee the light of God after death because they are too ashamed or too afraid to have their inner thoughts and negative natures revealed to everyone. (Dr. George Ritchie)

I saw the reasons for all of my actions and understood why I did what I had done. There was a place for all of my positive and negative actions. There was no action that was necessarily wrong, but there were actions I took that did not enhance positive growth. (David Oakford)

In hell, we have the opportunity to either revel in our folly or come to grips with the reality of consequences - that every action has a reaction, what is inflicted on another can be returned in kind. This is not a punishment for our sins but a confrontation with any distortion of our sense of values and priorities. (Dr. PMH Atwater)

Just knowing the bad mistakes you made through your carelessness or your selfishness is a hell. You don't need a devil prodding you with a fork. (Margaret Tweddell)

God does not condemn anyone to hell and there is no eternal damnation. We have the ability to condemn ourselves to the hell we create within ourselves. (Kevin Williams)

The God of love suffers for those in darkness, ignorance and misery. (Nora Spurgin)

Many people believe that those who don't give verbal assent to Jesus are cast headlong into eternal fire to burn forever. It should be common sense to anyone that a God of love would never treat people this way. As Jesus said, even an evil father knows how to give good things to children. (Kevin Williams)


These are opinions, beliefs, but they summarise what we know from over 30 years of studying NDEs. That's what Kevin has done above, present a synopsis of the research into NDEs.

The Traditional Hellfire and Brimstone NDEs

Why do some people have NDEs that resembles the fire and brimstone hell of the Bible while other people describe a different kind of hell? The quick answer is that there are many kinds of hells and many kinds of heavens. A person's situation in life and after death is based upon many factors including: perception, perspective, cultural and religious background, spirituality or lack thereof, and education. If you examine enough hellish NDEs that resemble the traditional hellfire and brimstone, you will notice that they mostly occur to fundamentalist Christians. Life after death often means "getting what you expect", that is, if you believe heaven is a place where you float on a cloud and play a harp, you just might get that when you die. And only when you realize that this kind of heaven is a fanatasy-to-be-abandoned will you find reality different. In other words, reality is what you make it. This applies on Earth as it is in heaven. If we believe that such a hell exists, it actually does exist - in our own minds. And since the afterlife is the realm of the mind and spirit, these hellish conditions actually exist merely by creating them in our own mind. This is why it is critical that we be careful what we put in our minds and what we build there. For more information about the differences between NDEs visit my NDE Differences page. (Kevin Williams)


As I said, I'm a Universalist, and I cannot even conceive of a God who is not, because such a God would be a tyrant:

NDEs Support Universal Salvation

What all people seek, what sustains them, is love, the light told me. What distorts people is a lack of love. The revelations coming from the light seemed to go on and on, then I asked the light, "Does this mean that humankind will be saved?" Then, like a trumpet blast with a shower of spiraling lights, the Great Light spoke, saying, "Remember this and never forget; you save, redeem and heal yourself. You always have. You always will. You were created with the power to do so from before the beginning of the world. In that instant I realized even more. I realized that WE HAVE ALREADY BEEN SAVED, and we saved ourselves because we were designed to self-correct like the rest of God's universe. (Mellen-Thomas Benedict)

Life is a cycle of improvements and humans are not perfect yet. Most people have this secret revealed to them when they die. (Dr. Frank Oski)

All souls were created in the beginning and are finding their way back to God. (Edgar Cayce)

We are immortal and indestructible. We have always been alive, we always will be, and there is no way in this world that we can ever be lost. It is impossible for anyone to fall into a crack in the universe somewhere and never be heard from again. We are utterly safe and we have always been forever and ever. (Jayne Smith)

From the light we have come, and to the light we all shall return. (Josiane Antonette)

It is God's love for us that sends us on our journey and it is our love for God that allows us to return to God's loving arms again. (David Goines)

A central aspect of our eternal existence is continued spiritual growth through love and service. We can spend what seems like an eternity before incarnating in the flesh. During that period in the spirit world, soul growth can be attained there as well. (Nora Spurgin)

It (reincarnation) is a universal process, and prevails not only in the human kingdom but also throughout the whole of nature. Whenever we find a living form, the consciousness of that form is also evolving, using temporarily for that purpose the physical form in order that it may gain physical experience. In each incarnation we have a different physical body, a different name, and may have different souls acting as parents, but these changes do not in the slightest imperil our individuality ... Reincarnation is not an endless process, and when we have learned the lessons taught in the World-School we return no more to physical incarnation unless we come back of our own accord to act as Teachers of humanity or as Helpers in the glorious plan of evolution. (Amber Wells)

Without physical bodies, feelings of hate and fear are intensified as souls [in hell] vainly try to hide from their enemies. Their only hope is to reincarnate. Then unfortunately when they do, they may forget all about their torment in hell and again lead lives of greed and tyranny. This miserable cycle can continue forever unless they find salvation in one of their lifetimes. Such people really need a savior, since they are not able to help themselves. I'm sure Christ incarnated to help them because he said, "I came not to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance." (Arthur Yensen)



The above is not based on any kind of "scriptural dogma", but empirical research into NDEs. In this sense, I do believe that the world's religions are important, as far as they impart, shall I call it "eternal truth". We all know what is right, and what is wrong, and the universal "law" is that we are rewarded with positive progression for chosing the right path, which is why we feel good when we do good things, and feel bad when we do wrong things, especially to others (but our consciences can become "seared" in this regard, for which there will be "karmic consequences"). We cannot escape the consequences of our actions, thoughts or words when they inflict harm on others, and this is, if you like, the "law of the universe". No one, not one single human being, is "beyond hope".
_twinkie
_Emeritus
Posts: 327
Joined: Fri Jan 12, 2007 4:01 am

Post by _twinkie »

What a really great question! I wonder (about the cows!). I totally believe in them. I read some of the links Ray posted- specifically Howard Strom's story and others on that same site. I have a relative that just recently had what he believes to be a NDE and his experience was much like Howard's- he has never been a religious person, but recalls being told in the back of his mind to pray and then "came back." I don't have the whole story, I expect he'll tell us in his own time.
_Gazelam
_Emeritus
Posts: 5659
Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2006 2:06 am

Post by _Gazelam »

Has Art Bell ever done a show about this? I'd love to hear what he has to say !
We can easily forgive a child who is afraid of the dark; the real tragedy of life is when men are afraid of the light. - Plato
_JoeNormal
_Emeritus
Posts: 5
Joined: Thu Mar 01, 2007 5:34 pm

Post by _JoeNormal »

This is a very cool thread. Most of the insights fall closely in line with what I was thinking when I had more time to be spiritual. I hope one day before long to get back to the practices that allow me to hear my inner voice. Anybody with kids, a house and a job; if you're already able to focus on your spiritual side, I applaud you. I've just been getting by.
_Julie
_Emeritus
Posts: 59
Joined: Tue Feb 27, 2007 9:26 pm

Post by _Julie »

I have never studied nde in any detail, but may or may not have had one. When having my wisdom teeth pulled in 1996 or thereabouts, the oral surgeon knocked me out either too much or not enough (not sure which)? I did see the ultra bright "white light" it was a warm and I must say completely peaceful feeling (no fear at all). However, I was aware of being at the dentist and recall vividly, wanting to ask the surgeon if I was dead or not, but of course I couldn't. It was like I could think but not communicate.
Well I did tell my husband and mom about it, but that was about it. I thought it was the drug that likely caused that experience. Then when I went to my regular dentist and said a tooth was bothering me he mentioned that it was odd, he said "the bottom wisdom teeth should have been extracted also, I don't understand why he didn't do it"? So I told him my story. I could tell he believed me, but forget his exact comment. To this day I wonder if I was actually close to death that afternoon, otherwise why would he not finish the work or even tell me he hadn't.
When I do die I hope it feels like that though, it was a very pleasurable feeling.
No, I'm not a nut! ;)
"If you want to save your child from polio, you can pray or you can inocculate". ~ Dr. Carl Sagan

"He didn't want to believe, he wanted to know". ~ Ann Druyan
Post Reply