Drifting wrote:
You see, this is why you are wrong.
In order for a dead person to have their proxy sealing done, they must first have had their proxy baptism done. Ergo they are (albeit dead) members of the Church.
Drifting,
I have been through this argument before with others. The Church is merely a vehicle being used to keep records in some semblance of order because God's Kingdom is a House of Order. Just because a dead person has had their ordinances performed does not, in reality, make them a member of the LDS Church. This is a technicality necessary in order to make sure that a dead person's ordinances have been performed by someone with the power and authority to do so. Since it is up to the dead person to either accept or reject the ordinances, that person is NOT LDS just because someone who WAS LDS stood in proxy for them. In other words, it is for administrative and mortal identification purposes only; and is only used in this mortal dispensation.
In other dispensations, there was no LDS Church. When Jesus gave the Keys to the Kingdom to Peter, there was no LDS Church. When Melchizedek lived during Abraham's time, there was no LDS Church. The Book of Mormon mentions no LDS Church. When Peter, James and John gave the Keys to the Kingdom to Joseph Smith, there was no LDS Church. When Christ returns and Satan is defeated, there will be no LDS Church. There are only two churches on the Earth. One is the Church of the Lamb of God (as it is called in the Book of Mormon), a.k.a. The Church of God (as it is called in the Bible), inside of which the LDS Church functions. The other is the Church of the Devil. "Official" membership in any historical or modern day church which represents belief in our Savior does NOT automatically make that member a true member of the Church of the Lamb of God (or a true member of the "body of Christ"). A True member of the Church of the Lamb of God MUST be born of the Spirit. The ordinances are a formality of the covenants which need to be made with God. The "sealing" of the Holy Spirit of Promise is the spiritual confirmation that a person has, indeed, been completely born of the Spirit, at which point the covenants which were made in the flesh allow a person to enter into Exaltation.
Whichever organization holds the Keys to the Kingdom of God in any particular dispensation holds the Power and Authority to bind or loose. They do not have exclusivity to the Kingdom of God - as the Kingdom of God is available to all of mankind. They do not have exclusivity to the Holy Ghost - as the Holy Ghost is available as a gift from God to all of mankind. The Messiah does not belong to the LDS Church. As I said before, the LDS Church is a vehicle. The LDS Church is NOT the Kingdom of God. Indeed, the LDS Church is a manifestation of the mortal world. It will not exist eternally.
Also, it is the Holy Spirit of Promise who ultimately seals/confirms that a Sealing performed in any dispensation has become accepted by Father. The sealings and loosenings, which need to be performed in the flesh, are NOT a guaranty that the Holy Spirit of Promise will place a spiritual confirmation upon them.
Your interpretation of these events is an error perpetuated by other members of the LDS Church who have also unintentionally been in error to support such a position.
Blessings,
jo