aussieguy55 wrote:Klaus Baer said in his Dialogue 1968 article that there no fibres in the glue. I agree the glue on the paper and the papyri placed over it.
fetchface wrote:I would think that brushing sticky glue on the fragile papyrus would be very problematic and would be likely to tear it. If I were gluing the papyrus to the paper, there is no way I would apply the glue to the papyrus. That'd be the dumb way to do it.
Plus, as aussieguy55 points out, there don't seem to be any signs that something was glued there and torn away.
I'm not saying that it is impossible but it just doesn't look likely to me.
However, the snout being removed on the woodcut looks very likely.
So first off I am not saying the glue was not first placed on the backing paper but I think the jury is still out.
First off, the 1968 Baer article was based on his examination of sepia copies of the papyri which were only available in the 1968 Feb Improvement Era magazine. So I am not sure how well he could actually tell about fibers from those photos. I own my own hard copy of the 1968 Era and those photos are not that great. Remember these are the photos Gee used to try and dishonestly claim there wasn't two colors of ink in any of the extant pieces. There isn't color anything in sepia photos, and since no one was allowed at that time, to actually examine the real papyri, no one could challenge him.
Secondly the 1st and second sections of the Hor scroll (maybe more) were originally glued as a single piece to a single sheet of paper then cut in two. See here for the second section. You will notice that in both sections, around the perimeter of each the jagged edges lie perfectly flat on the surface of the backing paper. This was a piece of papyri that was in roll form for over 2000 years and they are able to glue it flat perfectly so all edges stay down. How would one go about that?. Well if it were me, I would take the papyri and lay between two pieces of glass or something really flat. After it flattened out I would lay it face down on a flat surface, brush glue on the back of the papyri itself, then lay the backing paper on it, weighted down with another flat surface. Since the papyri is already resting on a flat firm surface, it would not be a problem to place glue on the back of it.
That method would explain why all the jagged areas lie flat on the backing paper while at the same time explain the lack of glue, for the most part out beyond the actual jagged edges of the papryi, on the backing paper.
I really don't think that the head of Anubis was there for Joseph, but I do think it strange that what appears to be glue runs from Anubis to Hor's waist.