Perfume on my Mind wrote:Imagine my delight to find a Shades criticism of Perfume! Holy large crap chunks! They are human to him after all!
Oh, I've expressed reservations before. For better or for worse, due to contractual obligations their music is 100% dependent on their songwriter / producer--who consists of a single guy only. They have expressed their desire to try their hand at writing some of their own songs and perhaps music, but he has shot them down every time because he loses money if he's not the sole contributor.
So, his unique vision has made their music great and set them apart from the mass-produced cookie-cutter artificially fabricated idol groups, but it's a double-edged sword, 'cause every time he swings and misses they are the ones who have to own it and play along anyway just the same as they do when he hits the home runs.
But the girls themselves are perfect, however. ;-)
To end on a lighter note, here's an EXTREMELY early version of them performing "Jenny's in a Bad Mood," most likely when they were still in school: Jenny's in a Bad Mood Look for Nocchi's hat and her funny reaction thereunto in the last few seconds.