Why Do LDS Dismiss the Greater Part of the New Testament?

The upper-crust forum for scholarly, polite, and respectful discussions only. Heavily moderated. Rated G.
Post Reply
_jo1952
_Emeritus
Posts: 1118
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 3:04 am

Re: Why Do LDS Dismiss the Greater Part of the New Testament

Post by _jo1952 »

Albion wrote:Jo, one or two responses to your last post. Firstly, I did read your original post but found it long and full of your own opinion rather than any appeal to specific scripture on any particular topic. Opinions which in my view are based on the false teachings of the Mormon Gospel. If I am wrong in referencing the early Mormon quote, attributed to God, that the beliefs of Christianity are an "abomination" and its believers "currupt", please show where that is inaccurate. Drifting in a follow up post gave the full text and it is clear what was said despite you accusing me of being dishonest with regard to it.


Hi Albion,

Do you not see? My comments were in response to the entire chapter of 1 John Chapter 4. Clearly, if you think that my comments were not based on any appeal to specific scripture on any particular topic, then we cannot even begin a discussion on common ground.

Not being RC I have not made, nor do I make, any defense of their position. While there is much in Catholicism that I might disagree with there are many devout Christians within that church and I think they are quite capable of defending their beliefs as Madelaine does with clarity on this very board.


However, the very issue which you are currently (through Drifting's quotations) accusing the LDS Church of, is a very specific teaching of the RCC. A reader without any biased pre-conception will read Drifting's quotations and NOT come to the same conclusion which you and Drifting have come to. Unfortunately, most posters on this site come to this site because it is specifically geared for Mormonism. As such, most already have an agenda filled with pre-conceptions as to why they come here in the first place.

I agree that there are many, many, many devout Christians who are Roman Catholics, of which Madeleine is one. However, I disagree that she has been able to defend her beliefs with clarity because she has only a surface understanding of her beliefs. She avoids more than half of the issues within the RCC belief system which have been presented to her. As such, she has completely avoided addressing them because she does not know how to. But she is on her own path. When she is ready and able to address those issues, she will.

If you have always used honesty in your posts on this board, then I think you are also devout in your belief system. Sometimes, though, and I could be way off base on this, I think that you are Drifting's sock puppet. If you are not, and your posts have been honest and sincere, then you ARE devout in your belief system. As I have previously mentioned, you are also on your own path. You and Madeleine are both at the points in your journey where you are comfortable; and they are based completely on your own choices. The same is true for where I am in my own journey.

I commend you in your declaration that you seek truth. Unfortunately, my experience is that Mormons only seek truth as they define it and when it conforms to what they have been told is truth.


I think this is true of the majority of all believers. It is the spiritually enlightened who are able to make distinctions and recognize Truth when they see or hear it. Sometimes they will discover that there is only partial Truth in what they have been taught by the religious institute they have been attending. Once they are spiritually enlightened they are able to find Truth anywhere and everywhere; and are able to filter out what is false. The more Truth that is revealed to them, the further they are able progress in their journey. These individuals exist all over the earth, and can be found in all religions. They will eventually become the "few there be that find it". And when their spirit IS completely born of the Spirit, they will be able to see the Kingdom of God; i.e., Exaltation.

A major leap is made in our journey when we begin to see the Light which allows to begin to make the distinction of seeing and hearing with spiritual eyes and ears. Just because someone else tells us that we have found that Light wherein our real spiritual journey can progress, does not mean that we HAVE found it. When we DO find it, we will know the difference.

Jesus is "the way, the truth and the life"...anyone seeking after truth begins and ends with him in a full understanding of who he is and the completeness of his atonement at Calvary. All truth resides in Christ Jesus and has been fully revealed...sufficient for our salvation. The rest is fluff and vain human reasoning and peacocking.


Jesus did reveal enough Truth sufficient for our salvation. However, Jesus did NOT reveal All Truth - only the parts of Truth which Father wanted Him to reveal. There is more than one level in Heaven where we can be saved to. In order to be in the same Heaven where God resides, we need to progress through the various lower levels of Heaven. Contrary to what you may think, this is not a uniquely LDS belief. Rather, it is an ancient belief. The Bible holds a myriad of levels of understanding, and in order see them and to be led to ALL Truth (some of which also exists outside of the Bible), we must do exactly what Jesus commanded: be perfect; which is also being completely born of the Spirit; which is also doing God's will as perfectly as Jesus did. When we have achieved this, we will have achieved Exaltation; we will be one with the Father. I believe this may also be akin to having our calling and election made sure which Peter speaks about. Also, this could be akin to be sealed by the Holy Spirit of Promise.

Where we are taught that through God's mercy we will be perfected, I think most misinterpret HOW this is achieved. I have created a post with which I am going to start a new thread. I have explained more there. It should be ready some time this evening.

Blessings,

jo
_Albion
_Emeritus
Posts: 1390
Joined: Mon May 07, 2012 9:43 pm

Re: Why Do LDS Dismiss the Greater Part of the New Testament

Post by _Albion »

One or two immediate thoughts. Firstly, in typical Mormon self righteousness you imply that you have some special spiritual insight denied to others not of your persuasion...a premise I reject completely so please avoid the condescension of speaking to a mere Christian like me in that manner. Secondly, again in typical Mormon fashion you downgrade Jesus declaring " Jesus did not reveal all truth". Jesus is all truth...God incarnate. Thirdly, only one level in heaven no matter how you twist scripture to demonstrate otherwise. (Please don't quote your proof text, I know what it is and I reject the Mormon interpretation of it). Fourthly, your Mormon third degree of heaven will be an awfully empty place if it is relying on Mormons becoming perfect through their own efforts. We become one with the Father through his free gift of grace in Jesus...Jesus' righteousness or perfection imputed to us through faith by grace alone. You can't be partially born of the spirit...you either are or you are not. Fifthly, I am quite capable of making my own posts without Drifting's input....as I am sure he is without mine. Insults are hardly becoming of someone working on perfection. Sixth, I have read Smith's version of his supposed vision (more than one version actually) and think it a dishonest to imply that he was talking only about RCs in his view. Perhaps there is yet another version of his first vision story I am unaware of where he is specific as you suggest....otherwise my point stands.
_Franktalk
_Emeritus
Posts: 2689
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 1:28 am

Re: Why Do LDS Dismiss the Greater Part of the New Testament

Post by _Franktalk »

Albion wrote:gdemetz, when someone proclaims himself superior to virtually all others in spirituality that is self righteous arrogance anyway you look at it and most definitely lacking in Christ-like humility. It is self posturing that can be disregarded.


I can see why you hold that view. Just a few years back I held the same for those who made the leap. They seemed like nut jobs and fairy tell weavers.

Just what am I to do? If I talk about what I know I will sound like I hold myself as superior to others. This is an unfortunate consequence of talking about spiritual issues. Am I not to describe how I made the trip and describe what I see now?

As I embrace the Kingdom of God I know for sure that all of God's spirit children are loved by God. I can at most times look past the outward man and know that a spirit rest inside each of us. A spirit that yearns to go back into the presence of the Father. When I talk to people who seek God yet are stuck in the world just what am I to say? When I talk about my spiritual path I can describe what I did and how I felt and what I experienced. You are right there is a difference between you and me. One of perception. But deep inside we are no different at all and the different places on the path are not far apart even though they seem that way. I wish everyone could enjoy the Good Word and see each other as we actually are. But until that day comes we will fight and we will disagree.

Just how do you read scripture? Do you see Paul as arrogant when he tried to teach the Jews of Christ? And just what did some of the Jews say to Paul when he spoke of Christ? Ask yourself if Paul was talking about himself or was he telling others what he knew was truth. And just where did this truth come from? It came from the Holy Ghost and it was not of Paul. If you wish to disregard me I have no problem with that. But don't disregard scripture. Read what Paul and others say about the spirit.

Act 2:4, Act 2:17, Act 2:18, Act 5:9, Act 6:10, Act 7:59, Act 8:29, Act 8:39, Act 10:19, Act 11:12, Act 11:28, Act 16:7, Act 16:16, Act 16:18, Act 17:16, Act 18:5, and of course many others.

Ask yourself why is it that so many ignore the spirit in scripture? Being filled with the spirit is not just a saying it is an actual event with real consequences.
_Albion
_Emeritus
Posts: 1390
Joined: Mon May 07, 2012 9:43 pm

Re: Why Do LDS Dismiss the Greater Part of the New Testament

Post by _Albion »

Wonderful scriptures every one...I have no problem with any of them. It is your self agrandizement I have the problem with. I wonder if God is impressed the way you are with yourself?
_Franktalk
_Emeritus
Posts: 2689
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 1:28 am

Re: Why Do LDS Dismiss the Greater Part of the New Testament

Post by _Franktalk »

Albion wrote:Wonderful scriptures every one...I have no problem with any of them. It is your self agrandizement I have the problem with. I wonder if God is impressed the way you are with yourself?


God loves us all Albion, why do you try and use Him as a weapon? We all struggle in this world. None of us have all the answers.

Act 7:58 And cast him out of the city, and stoned him: and the witnesses laid down their clothes at a young man's feet, whose name was Saul.
Act 7:59 And they stoned Stephen, calling upon God, and saying, Lord Jesus, receive my spirit.
Act 7:60 And he kneeled down and cried with a loud voice, Lord, lay not this sin to their charge. And when he had said this, he fell asleep.

Did God love Stephen? Why did God allow the stoning if God loved Stephen? Did God love Saul who was in the crowd that stoned Stephen? For me God loved both men. The one being stoned and the one who was supporting the stoning. So how can God love either of us more than the other? Where you see a vast gulf between us I don't believe God sees any difference at all.

Did Saul love God as he was supporting the stoning of Stephen? I think Saul thought he was doing God's work. Was Saul doing God's work? I think he was. Did God use Saul to provide a chance for Stephen to lay down his life for Jesus?

Albion, God is involved in everything we do. His hand is upon all of us. If you allow your self to see it you will.
_Albion
_Emeritus
Posts: 1390
Joined: Mon May 07, 2012 9:43 pm

Re: Why Do LDS Dismiss the Greater Part of the New Testament

Post by _Albion »

I am reminded of Paul's statement that all our works are "as filthy rags" in God's sight. Only in humility, accepting the full sacrifice of Jesus at Calvary as a total redemption can we have any standing before God..."..not by works (of which boasting in some superior spirituality is one) lest any man boast..." The problem is not that I see a vast difference between us, we are both sinners in need of God's saving grace, but I do see the false difference that you have placed there yourself as you boast in your claim of some superior spirituality. I repeat, I have nothing, absolutely nothing, to commend me to God except the saving grace through faith in Jesus Christ. Like Paul, that redemption is the only thing in which I boast.

I had no real problem with your last post....a great deal of rightness there...but then you added the last sentence and reverted back to the idea that if somehow I could just see things with the same level of claimed spirituality that you have then I'll be okay. I don't want to see things as you do....I want to see things as God does through his holy word and as exemplified by the life of his Son.
_Tobin
_Emeritus
Posts: 8417
Joined: Wed Feb 01, 2012 6:01 pm

Re: Why Do LDS Dismiss the Greater Part of the New Testament

Post by _Tobin »

Albion wrote:I am reminded of Paul's statement that all our works are "as filthy rags" in God's sight. Only in humility, accepting the full sacrifice of Jesus at Calvary as a total redemption can we have any standing before God..."..not by works (of which boasting in some superior spirituality is one) lest any man boast..." The problem is not that I see a vast difference between us, we are both sinners in need of God's saving grace, but I do see the false difference that you have placed there yourself as you boast in your claim of some superior spirituality. I repeat, I have nothing, absolutely nothing, to commend me to God except the saving grace through faith in Jesus Christ. Like Paul, that redemption is the only thing in which I boast.

I had no real problem with your last post....a great deal of rightness there...but then you added the last sentence and reverted back to the idea that if somehow I could just see things with the same level of claimed spirituality that you have then I'll be okay. I don't want to see things as you do....I want to see things as God does through his holy word and as exemplified by the life of his Son.


I too really don't have much of a problem with what Frank posted below, but like you, was left feeling a bit flat and disheartened by his last comment. I couldn't follow it. IF, as Frank claims, God is involved in everything, wouldn't his hand already be upon all of us?!? So is it really necessary for us to see it they way Frank does. I don't believe so. I think we each bring our own perspective to the table. I value the fact people share their views. It improves my own, but I don't for a moment think any of us "truly" can represent that we speak for God (nor should we try).
"You lack vision, but I see a place where people get on and off the freeway. On and off, off and on all day, all night.... Tire salons, automobile dealerships and wonderful, wonderful billboards reaching as far as the eye can see. My God, it'll be beautiful." -- Judge Doom
_Albion
_Emeritus
Posts: 1390
Joined: Mon May 07, 2012 9:43 pm

Re: Why Do LDS Dismiss the Greater Part of the New Testament

Post by _Albion »

I think that overall I agree with you. It is not my role to judge anyone and I have studiously avoided any personal attack on anyone on this board...though I have been called a whole variety of names in return. I have perhaps been guilty of flippancy but usually in response to those who would, in my view, arrogantly put down my own personal relationship with God to elevate theirs above it. I do believe that God's word speaks for itself and that he has a personal and continuing interest in our lives and draws us to him in every way possible because of that interest and his desire for our eternal well being. Nothing happens in God's planning by accident.
_Franktalk
_Emeritus
Posts: 2689
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 1:28 am

Re: Why Do LDS Dismiss the Greater Part of the New Testament

Post by _Franktalk »

Tobin wrote:I too really don't have much of a problem with what Frank posted below, but like you, was left feeling a bit flat and disheartened by his last comment. I couldn't follow it. IF, as Frank claims, God is involved in everything, wouldn't his hand already be upon all of us?!? So is it really necessary for us to see it they way Frank does. I don't believe so. I think we each bring our own perspective to the table. I value the fact people share their views. It improves my own, but I don't for a moment think any of us "truly" can represent that we speak for God (nor should we try).


I believe there are many paths to God and between you and God that path happens. So my path is for me. But there are basics. The real path does not start until you at least acknowledge the possibility of a God. The disconnect to the world can happen many ways that I am not aware of. So me sharing my experiences only directly affects me. But the fact we are talking about a path to God is a good start.
_Franktalk
_Emeritus
Posts: 2689
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 1:28 am

Re: Why Do LDS Dismiss the Greater Part of the New Testament

Post by _Franktalk »

Albion wrote:I don't want to see things as you do....I want to see things as God does through his holy word and as exemplified by the life of his Son.


But you have missed the point yet again. His Word is NOT the witness for us. And until you get that straight you will go around in circles.

1Jo 5:8 And there are three that bear witness in earth, the spirit, and the water, and the blood: and these three agree in one.

Notice the Word is left out. This is done on purpose because:

1Jo 5:7 For there are three that bear record in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost: and these three are one.

The Holy Ghost will guide you to truth on the earth and in heaven. The Word is not for the flesh to know without help on the earth. If you are not guided then all readings are of man and will be wrong on the earth.

There are some simple truths in scripture. Little stepping stones that guide us to the Holy Ghost.
Post Reply