Themis wrote:The CCC wrote:Then punish the action. Your thoughts are between you and your conscience. Your actions are between you and the law.
No one is punishing peoples thoughts. That doesn't mean we shouldn't try to get people to get rid of bad ideas that can lead to bad outcomes and actions. I know that I usually have to add, to people who always think the worst, is that I am not suggesting we try and force people to change beliefs. I never even suggested it yet why is this where it seems to go with some people?
Polygamy was a matter of commandment. For those not given the command there is no responsibility, or expectation to obey.
I know what Joseph was doing. The issue is that he said one thing and did another. He lied about it. He made rules in which he never intended that he would follow. He manipulated people to get what he wanted.
No one that I know has ever denied that Joseph Smith had multiple wives. Plus the women were always free to say no. The women that I know aren't mindless sheep.
You say you are a social scientist but show so much ignorance in how people can abuse and manipulate others. It is not the black and white world you are trying to see here. Mindless sheep is a straw-man. Most people may not be mindless sheep, but most are not free of the influence of their environment. If the world were as you think frauds would have little success. battered women would all leave husbands and boyfriends. The easiest person to manipulate into things they would not normally do is the believer. I suspect Joseph had little success manipulating the unbeliever in his claims. It is a common trait of religious leaders(especially founders) to use their position to gain sexual access to adherents. Especially the young who are more easily manipulated. Interesting you will condemn others but not Joseph for doing the same things. The bias of the believer to their cause. I've been there, and even now I am not free of those influences.
You are not paying attention. My objections to polygamy are not based on the law. Marry whomever as many times as you want. It really is none of my concern. My objections are based on my personal feelings. I have no desire for more than the one wife I've has for the last 43 years. Plus sociologically it is a dead end. About 103 males are born for every 100 females. If all survive to reproduce with polygamy relatively soon there won't be enough females to continue polygamy.
Your objections seem non-existent to what we are really talking about. Joseph's willingness to say one thing and do another. You don't seem to object to his lying about it. Or his breaking laws he says he believes in sustaining. Or how about not following his own claimed revelations about polygamy. Hard to and still want to believe he was God's messenger.
I really don't care what people believe. One can believe in vampires, as long as they don't turn into Buffy the Vampire Slayer that belief is between them and their conscience.
I don't have a problem with talking with people about almost any subject they want. Albeit somethings I know more about than other things. I'm the worlds foremost expert on what I believe
It is right there is in D&C 132. He held others to the same standard. By commandment. That some took the authority on their own to become polygamous is not the fault of Joseph Smith.
Believe me I know very well that some choose to manipulate and control others. To play into people's emotions rather than the intellect is a time worn trait of demagogues and tyrants alike. Joseph Smith was neither.
That is a trait common to many including those that abuse religion for their own sexual gratification(Some Hindu beliefs about sex withstanding). What is very rare is for them to marry them, and thus incur all the financial obligations attendant to marriage.
I object to anyone lying, but it needs to be tempered by circumstance. There is no good answer when a wife asks if "Does this dress make me look fat?" by the way Emma was present at least some of the polygamous marriage ceremonies.
It was the law to murder, and/or drive from the state the LDS. Do you really expect the LDS to follow that law?
Whether you believe it or not is up to you. As for me and my house we will follow the Lord's servants.